You have finished the book. You have read it so many times that you can no longer see it. Your family says it is wonderful, a friend from your writing group says chapter four drags, and you have no idea which of them is right.
This is the moment most authors ask the same question: is my manuscript ready for publishers? A manuscript assessment is how you get an answer before a publisher gives you one.
What a Manuscript Assessment Is
A manuscript assessment is a reader's report on an unpublished book. It tells you what works, what does not, and what to fix first. It is different from editing. An editor changes your sentences; an assessment tells you whether the book as a whole holds together, and where it does not.
A useful assessment answers two different questions, and it helps to keep them apart:
- Is it well written? Structure, pacing, character, voice, clarity, and the polish of the prose. This is craft.
- Will readers want it? The premise, how clearly the book knows its audience, how it compares with books already on the shelf, and whether it stands out. This is market.
A book can be strong on one and weak on the other. A beautifully written novel with a very small audience and a fast, commercial book with rough prose need completely different advice. An assessment that blends the two into one verdict hides the thing you most need to know.
Signs Your Manuscript May Not Be Ready Yet
Before you pay anyone for an assessment, read your own draft against these questions. If you cannot answer them, a publisher's first reader probably cannot either.
- 1Can you say what the book is about in one or two sentences? If your logline needs a paragraph, the book may not yet know what it is.
- 2Do you know who it is for? "Everyone" is not a reader. Name the books your reader already loves.
- 3Does the opening earn the next page? Submissions are often judged on the first chapters alone.
- 4Does the middle move? Many drafts sag in the middle third, where the setup is done and the ending is not yet in sight.
- 5Does every main character want something? Characters who only react make a book feel slow even when a lot happens.
- 6Is the prose clean? Typos and inconsistent names tell a reader the author stopped revising too early.
- 7Have you finished it? For fiction especially, a complete manuscript is generally expected before submission. Non-fiction is sometimes pitched with a proposal and sample chapters instead; check what each publisher asks for.
If several of these give you pause, that is normal. It is also exactly what an assessment should help you fix.
What Publishers and Agents Usually Ask For
Submission rules differ from publisher to publisher, and they change, so always read the current guidelines on each publisher's or agent's own website before you send anything. Most submissions are built from the same few pieces:
- A query or cover letter: a short introduction to you and the book.
- A synopsis: the whole story, ending included, in a page or two.
- Sample chapters: usually the opening chapters, not your favourite ones.
- The full manuscript: sent only when it is asked for.
Each of these is judged on its own. A strong book with a weak synopsis can be passed over before anyone reads chapter one, so it is worth assessing the synopsis as well as the book.
How ProofBooks Assesses a Manuscript
ProofBooks was built for Indian authors to get this kind of read, with numbers you can track from one draft to the next. There are two ways to start.
The free Snapshot: start with your synopsis
Paste a synopsis of up to 10,000 characters. The free Snapshot gives you a score from 0 to 100, the genre, a logline, comparable books, and the main strengths and weaknesses of your synopsis. It needs only a free account. Because it reads the synopsis rather than the book, treat it as a check on your pitch and a first signal, not a verdict on the manuscript.
Premium Analysis: the manuscript itself
Upload the manuscript as a PDF, Word (.docx), plain text or EPUB file, up to 50 MB. Premium reads the manuscript itself, not a synopsis. Very long books are read within a page limit, so for those the analysis works from a sample of the book's pages rather than every page.
The report scores craft and market separately, each out of 100, and then goes through the book in detail:
- Craft scores and market scores
- Pacing, tension and emotional-rhythm curves across the book
- Character depth
- Comparable books
- Chapter highlights, and passages worth another look
- A rewrite roadmap, in priority order
- Back-cover blurbs and a cover design brief
- A query letter draft
- A launch strategy
- An adaptation and rights brief
The rewrite roadmap is the part to start with. It puts the problems in the order to fix them, so your next revision goes where it counts.
Where your book lands
Your band is set by the stronger of your two scores, so a book with outstanding craft and a small market is still recognised for its craft:
| Band | Score |
|---|---|
| ProofBooks Masterpiece | 90+ |
| ProofBooks Elite | 80–89 |
| ProofBooks Recommends | 70–79 |
| Industry Ready | 60–69 |
| Developing | 45–59 |
| Early Draft | 0–44 |
A band is a measure of this draft, not of you. Most first drafts are not meant to land at the top; the point is to see the number move as you revise.
Read in the language you write in
ProofBooks reads manuscripts in English, Tamil, Hindi, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Bengali, Gujarati and Punjabi. You tell us the language your book is written in; it is never guessed, so a Tamil novel is read as Tamil literature. The report itself can be written in English, Tamil or Hindi.
You also tell us what kind of book it is, fiction, non-fiction, children's, poetry or academic, and then the genre or reader age, so the book is read for what it is.
Your manuscript stays yours
Your manuscript is never published. Only scores you choose to show appear on your profile, and a Premium analysis can be marked private so that it publishes nothing anywhere. If a paid analysis fails, it can be retried once at no charge.
Before you decide, you can read real sample reports we ran on books you know, unedited.
A Simple Plan Before You Submit
- 1Revise until you can answer the seven questions above.
- 2Check your pitch. Run your synopsis through the free Snapshot and tighten the logline until it is clear.
- 3Get the full read. When the draft is as good as you can make it alone, order a Premium Analysis and work through the rewrite roadmap.
- 4Revise and compare. Assess the new draft the same way and see whether the craft and market scores moved.
- 5Register the version you send. Before the manuscript leaves your hands, register it so there is a dated, checkable record of exactly what you sent.
- 6Follow each publisher's guidelines exactly, and keep a simple record of who you sent what, and when.
The Bottom Line
No assessment can promise a publishing deal, and you should be wary of anyone who says otherwise. What a good assessment can do is show you, before a publisher does, where your book is strong and where it is not, so your submission is the best version of the book you can write.
Start with your synopsis. Send the manuscript when you want the whole picture.